Jennipher Martinez
Professor Jaxon
English 332
10/05/2013
Just Girls Table 2
Just Girls was a very fun book to read as it reminded me of middle school. Our table discussed our experiences with writing notes, passing notes, having acronyms for different things, signing yearbooks and reading teen magazines. It was what we enjoyed doing the most at thirteen. Margaret Finders exploration of the literacy practices of girls in the late 90’s really captures what it was for teenagers to read and communicate before I-pads, and smartphones. It help remind me of how it was like to transition from an elementary way of reading and writing to a more adult way of going about it.
Northern Hills Junior High was somewhat like my middle school when it came to the social scene, we did have our fair share of “Social Queens” and “Tough Cookies”. As bullying is not very present in this book, cliques are seen as some present themselves as superior to others. I could just imagine what it would be like if there technology involved in this book, and in my middle school. As before the biggest worries of a teenager was for the teacher to read your notes out loud to the class, there biggest nightmare now would be to take their phone away. Even though we did have cellphones in that point in time not everyone had one, and also not everyone had internet or texting. Texting in class didn’t become an issue until half-way through high school.
The yearbook signing was also something that was relatable to me as a teen. I did buy them as for me they were affordable, and although I was probably in it like once or twice, I still bought it for the memories. In the book we see some of the girls did not buy the yearbook simply because they couldn’t afford and or they believe it was irrelevant because they weren’t in it. For me the signing of the yearbook was very important as it was a way of communicating a nice message to a fellow classmate that could possibly be there next year or not. Not everyone signed everyone’s yearbook; some people were selective just like the “Queens” in the book Just Girls
Another key point is where we see Lauren appear to not like reading but very much enjoyed too at home. I remember in middle school being smart meant you were a nerd or geek, so having good grades wasn’t cool. Lauren forgot on purpose not to bring her book, to make her seem like she didn’t care and in a way seem like she didn’t have too, like how I mentioned before as to look superior to others. She cared more about looking cool than learning which the reason she was going to school was. As Lauren’s teacher later found out that Lauren loved reading sports fiction that inspired some teachers to have a different way of teaching, by allowing students to choose what they wanted to read. This way they would get the teens to read and enjoy doing it. Even though some teachers saw this plan as successful, I would have to disagree for me, as a teen choosing something to read in my younger lazier years would have gone with the easiest option. Something that has a movie linked to it, and probably has a lot of Cliff notes. But since this was before technology and Google maybe it would have been successful then but not now.